Showing posts with label The Ends Principle. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Ends Principle. Show all posts

Saturday, September 17, 2016

A Saber-toothed Criticism

As I read J. Abner Peddiwell's The Saber-tooth Curriculum, I found myself frequently nodding my head in agreement. My poor (non-teacher) husband had to sit through lengthy passages that I just "had to read out loud" to him. So much of Peddiwell's criticism hit home.


Unfortunately, despite its original publishing date of 1939, so many of Peddiwell's thoughts and allegories still ring true today. A poorly-designed educational system not only opens a society up to attack, as seen by the warrior tribe in the text, but also leads to a steep economic/social decline of the society itself. By the end of the story, there is a deep divide between the "haves" (greedy fish chiefs/corrupt Wall Street execs?) and the "have nots" (paleo-youth playing with rocks to pass the time/"educated" Millennials drowning in student loans who can't find jobs in their fields of study?).


All of these problems stem from the main theme that the instruction students receive is completely inauthentic. Nothing that these children and young adults are expected to learn has any real-life connection to what their current community needs. Although the original system developed by New-Fist was authentic to the community of his time, as the needs of that community evolved the lessons taught to their youth remained the same.


Peddiwell's dystopic description of general education then/today also applies to modern foreign language instruction. There is a huge paradigm shift going on right now (well, attempting to, anyway) about how we teach our students language and what language acquisition actually looks like. The "old ways" of grammar-translation and audio-lingual methodologies (think workbook pages with grammar exercises and "dialogs" that have to be memorized) are still deeply rooted in language classrooms and curricula all over the country.


"New wave" instructors using comprehensible input (CI) and communicative language teaching (CLT) methods are constantly fighting against these traditional ideologies. We are sometimes successful, but often we run into a lot of the same resistance found in Sabertooth (such as the progressive teacher who started her “Real-Creek School of Fish-Grabbing”). Many curricula still insist on explicit grammar instruction and inauthentic "communication" exercises as means of assessment.


Language acquisition experts such as Stephen Krashen and Bill VanPatten are working to challenge these traditional approaches and change instruction to be more authentic, communicative, and reflective of natural acquisition. I have found great success following their advice, using CI, TPRS, MovieTalk, Communicative Tasks and other strategies in my lessons. The links below describe their theories and research to those who are curious:
http://www.educ.ualberta.ca/staff/olenka.bilash/best%20of%20bilash/krashen.html
http://learninglanguages.celta.msu.edu/sla-vanpatten/